Don't Be That Way (S.Nestico)

Edgar Sampson’s timeless swing anthem "Don't Be That Way," co-written with Benny Goodman and Mitchell Parish, stands as one of the definitive swing era masterpieces, famously serving as the explosive opening theme for Goodman’s legendary 1938 Carnegie Hall concert. This iconic composition captures the sophisticated, driving momentum of the late 1930s big band tradition, blending infectious rhythmic propulsion with memorable, harmonically rich melodic lines that immediately engage both performers and audiences alike. In this masterful adaptation crafted by legendary powerhouse drummer Louie Bellson, the chart explodes with the high-octane energy and meticulous precision synonymous with Bellson’s stellar writing career. Propelled by a vibrant, driving medium-up swing feel in 4/4 time, the arrangement balances roaring, full-ensemble power with intricate, tightly knit brass and reed interplay. Bellson infuses Sampson's classic melodies with sparkling modern harmonic touches, brilliant dynamic contrast, and a relentless forward swing that captures the exhilaration of the historic big band golden age while injecting contemporary rhythmic vitality. The musical architecture of this 18-instrument chart showcases brilliant sectional writing, featuring lush sax solis and electrifying shout choruses that build organically throughout the form. The melody is shared fluidly across the brass and reed families, creating a dynamic textural dialogue, while ample space is provided for standout improvised solos from the lead horns. Technical challenges lie primarily in maintaining crisp articulation, precise swing eighth-note subdivision at brisk tempos, and seamless balance during dense counterpoint sections. Achieving the signature Bellson punch requires disciplined dynamic control, particularly in the lower brass and rhythm section, ensuring the underlying groove remains buoyant and unforced. Advanced high school ensembles, collegiate jazz orchestras, and professional big bands will find this sophisticated chart an exceptionally rewarding centerpiece for concerts and festival repertoires. The arrangement demands seasoned section playing and rhythmic maturity, making it an ideal vehicle for showcasing a band's versatility, dynamic range, and mastery of authentic swing style. Conductors should approach this chart with a primary focus on relentless, relaxed swing eighth-note accuracy, avoiding any tendency to rush the medium-up tempo. The rhythm section acts as the ultimate engine here; the drummer should channel Louie Bellson's signature propulsion by keeping a steady, conversational ride cymbal pattern while utilizing crisp, tasteful accents that complement the horn lines without overpowering them. Brass players must execute falls, doits, and plunger or cup mute effects (where indicated) with clean precision rather than exaggerated volume, ensuring the underlying harmony remains clear. Rehearsal time should be heavily dedicated to the delicate interplay of the inner voices during the sax soli, ensuring every articulation matches across the section. Balance is crucial during the dynamic swells leading into the final shout chorus; hold back the initial peaks so the ultimate climax of the arrangement achieves maximum emotional and acoustic impact. Q: What instruments and parts are included in this big band arrangement? A: This standard 18-instrument big band chart includes full instrumentation consisting of two alto saxophones, two tenor saxophones, one baritone saxophone, a full brass section, and a complete rhythm section. Q: What is the difficulty level of this Louie Bellson arrangement? A: This arrangement is graded as advanced, making it best suited for collegiate jazz orchestras, professional big bands, and high-level high school ensembles with strong section leaders and experienced soloists. Q: What is the historical context and stylistic feel of "Don't Be That Way"? A: Originally composed by Edgar Sampson and made famous by the Benny Goodman Orchestra, this piece is a cornerstone of the swing era, performed here with a driving, high-energy medium-up swing feel. Q: What makes this specific arrangement by Louie Bellson unique? A: Bellson's treatment elevates Edgar Sampson's classic theme by injecting signature powerhouse rhythmic hits, sophisticated harmonic voicings, and meticulously crafted shout choruses that reflect a master drummer's deep understanding of big band dynamics. Q: What is the approximate performance duration and tempo of this chart? A: While performance time can vary slightly based on the number of improvised choruses taken, the chart operates at an energetic medium-up swing tempo typically lasting around 3 to 4 minutes.